Monday, 29 June 2009

Comparision of two music videos




I chose to compare two music videos one being Girls aloud biology and the other being The saturdays work. In both videos there is five girls and they all are dancing in the videos to the music. Although in the Saturdays video the focus moves from the group as a whole to individuals when they are singing and dancing. Also in the girls aloud video there is only focus on the group and there are no other people apart from the group in the video unlike the Saturdays work when there are male dancers and a little girl at the start of the video.

There is no intertextuality that i can see within both of the video. Also there is no link between the lyrics and the video in the girls aloud song. Whereas there is a link between the lyrics and the video for the Saturdays video work as the men come in and dance with them and the lyrics say about the man working for them and the men are actually working for them as they are dancing for them. There is also no links between the music and the videos for either of the groups.

There is alot of voyeurism in both videos especially in the saturdays video as the girls are more skimpily clad and look more sexual as they have more flesh showing. Rather than the girls in the girls aloud video although they look pretty they dont look as sexual as The Saturdays.
In both of the videos by both groups the girls seem to be promoting them selves by their looks and showing of there sexuality. Both videos seem to be more appealing to men although women view the girls and see them as role models and aspire to them.







No comments:

Post a Comment